The Old Mill - Roxbury: A Culinary Gem in the Heart of Upstate New York

Welcome to The Old Mill - Roxbury, a hidden gem nestled in the scenic backdrop of Roxbury, New York. Located at 2318 Co Rd 41, this quaint restaurant combines rustic charm with a warm, inviting atmosphere. With a buzz of camaraderie in the air, it sets the perfect stage for an unforgettable dining experience.

Upon arrival, guests might experience a brief moment of uncertainty, as indicated in a review by Dawn Morgan. The entrance features a cozy deck that is still a work in progress—a small detail that does not overshadow the delights awaiting inside. While there may have been a hiccup in the opening time, the interior reveals a beautiful space that feels both intimate and welcoming.

As you settle in, expect to be greeted by an attentive and friendly staff. Reviewers like Steve Grabkowski praise the courteous service and the fresh, flavorful appetizers—particularly the steamed mussels in white wine, garlic, and butter, which have earned high acclaim. The restaurant's specials, such as the perfectly cooked roasted ribeye, are also a must-try, showcasing the kitchen's commitment to quality and culinary excellence.

Many visitors have remarked on the surprisingly remarkable salads. Colleen Maynard mentions that their arugula and garden salads might just be the best she’s ever had. Such praises reflect the restaurant’s dedication to using fresh ingredients, elevating even the simplest of dishes to new heights.

The ambiance contributes greatly to the overall experience. With a cozy dining room and laid-back service, guests like Arielle Tschinkel feel the love and attention that goes into each meal. Although the menu may appear limited, every dish is crafted with care, showcasing local flavors and seasonal ingredients. It creates a sense of connection between the diner and the rich culture of Roxbury.

For anyone traveling to this picturesque town, a stop at The Old Mill - Roxbury is strongly recommended. Whether you're in for a full meal or a quick appetizer and drink, you will leave with a sense of joy and contentment. With its charming atmosphere and delicious food, this restaurant is bound to enchant and delight.

Outdoor seating
Takeaway
Dine-in
Delivery

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Credit cards
Debit cards

Dawn Morgan

19/09/2025

Started out a little weird. Walked up to the front of the building and the deck was unfinished, a bit of a safety hazard but we walked up close to the door so as not to step where the missing decking boards were. Was supposed to be open at 5pm but someone told us through the window that they weren't quite ready to open yet and to give them another 15 minutes. (?) We waited until 5:30 to try again. Really cool place on the inside. Server was very pleasant. Our food was really good. I do agree with another reviewer that the bread was a bit burnt but I've had worse.

Steve Grabkowski

18/08/2025

While my wife were in the area we stopped in for dinner. The atmosphere was nice, our server was very kind and courteous. We ordered several appetizers which came out fairly quickly and everyone of them were fresh and flavorful, especially the steamed muscles in white wine butter and garlic, amazing! Ordered the roasted rib eye as it was one of their specials for the day, cooked perfectly and very tender. Highly recommend if your travels take you to this small town, you won't be disappointed!

Colleen Maynard

15/07/2025

This is going to sound weird but our salads (arugula and garden) were maybe the best we’ve ever had. Our entrees did not disappoint. The cozy dining room and laid back service was just what we were looking for after a busy day.

Arielle Tschinkel

30/06/2025

we have visited a few times during trips to The Roxbury, and it's always a delight. the atmosphere is lovely and the service is warm and inviting. the food is excellent. the menu is a bit limited, but the dishes are clearly prepared with lots of love and attention, so it's well worth a stop if you're staying close by.

Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *